Provisional sums and variations explained
Two phrases in a quote cause more arguments than any others: provisional sum and variation. Understanding them is the cheapest protection you can buy.
What a provisional sum is
A provisional sum is a placeholder in a quote for work that cannot yet be priced accurately. It might be for a part of the job where the details are not decided, or where the builder cannot see what is behind a wall. The actual cost is settled later, and it can be higher or lower.
What a prime cost sum is
A prime cost sum is an allowance for something you will choose, such as tiles, a kitchen or sanitaryware. If you choose something that costs more than the allowance, you pay the difference. If you choose something cheaper, you should get the saving. Check what the allowance covers, including fixing and delivery.
Why they exist
In an older house, some things are only discovered once work starts. In any job, some choices are not made until later. Provisional and prime cost sums are an honest way to deal with that. Quotes with too many of them, though, are really estimates.
The warning signs
Large or vague provisional sums for work that could be priced. Allowances that look unrealistically low for what is described, which can make the headline price look attractive. No explanation of what the sum covers. If one quote has far fewer provisional sums than another, the two are not directly comparable.
How to keep them under control
Ask for each provisional sum to be itemised, with a note of what is included and what is not. Ask when it will be firmed up and how you will be told. Ask what happens if the real cost is higher. Make your choices early so the sum turns into a fixed price.
What a variation is
A variation is a change to the agreed work, whether you asked for it or something unforeseen made it necessary. It might be extra work, omitted work or a change of material. Variations are normal. The danger is in agreeing them casually on site.
Agree variations in writing
Before the extra work is done, agree the change, the cost and the effect on the time, in writing. A message or email is enough. Date it and keep it. Verbal agreements at the end of the day are where disputes start.
Contingency
Setting aside a contingency of your own, outside the contract, is sensible, especially for older houses. If you do not use it, it is yours. If you need it, it is there. Be careful about telling anyone the size of it.
An example of how it works
Suppose a quote includes an allowance for tiling, and you choose tiles that cost more than the allowance. The difference is added to the final account. If you find that the plaster behind the old kitchen is failing, the builder should tell you, show you and agree the cost of putting it right before doing it. No figures here are real, but the principle is the same on every job.
Ask your builder to talk you through how it would work on your job.
Questions to ask before you sign
Which items are provisional? What is each one based on? Who decides when it is firmed up? How are variations priced, by day rate or by fixed price? Will I get a written price before extra work starts? What is the process for a disagreement? A good builder answers these easily.
Comparing quotes fairly
When you have more than one quote, lay them side by side and list the provisional sums and allowances in each. Ask the builders to price the same items on the same basis. A quote that looks cheaper may simply have lower allowances, and a quote that looks dearer may be more honest. The aim is to compare like with like, and a bit of work at this stage can save a lot of argument later.
Final account
At the end, the final account should show the original price, the provisional sums as adjusted and each variation. If it matches your records, there are no surprises. If not, you have the paperwork to discuss it.
Related pages
- What to get in writing before work starts
- How long does a building project take?
- Extensions and additions
Free site visit and quote
Tell us about the project at hello@margatebuilders.co.uk or on WhatsApp. We'll arrange a site visit to give you a proper quote.